Site Links HomeMedicare BasicsBlog ArticlesFind an AgentTurning 65 Medicare Answers Call a Local AgentFind the Right Plan LEGAL Privacy Policy©2020 LMS Insurance, LLC – All Rights Reserved5 star plan ratingPublished on: 05/09/2023

Shining a Light on Medicare Plan Quality: Part D and Medicare Advantage Star Ratings

Navigating the complex world of Medicare can be challenging, especially when it comes to choosing the right plan for your individual needs. With so many Medicare Advantage and Part D Prescription Drug Plans available, it's essential to have a reliable way to evaluate their quality and performance. In this article, we'll shine a light on the Medicare Star Ratings system, a valuable tool designed to help beneficiaries make informed decisions about their healthcare coverage.

The star rating system serves as a guide to understanding the quality of Medicare Advantage and Part D prescription drug plans, allowing you to compare different options based on their performance across several key areas. By the end of this article, you'll have a clear understanding of what star ratings are, how they're calculated, and how you can use them to choose a plan that best aligns with your healthcare needs and priorities.

What Are Medicare Star Ratings?

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) introduced the Medicare star rating system as a way to measure and communicate the overall quality and performance of Medicare Advantage (Part C) and Part D prescription drug plans. The star ratings provide an objective assessment of these plans, helping beneficiaries like you make informed decisions about your Medicare plan options.

The star ratings take into account a wide range of factors that contribute to the quality of a Medicare plan. These factors are grouped into five main categories.

Quality of Care: This category evaluates the plan's ability to deliver effective ad appropriate care. It includes measures such as preventive screenings, chronic disease management, and the overall health outcomes of plan members.

Access to Care: This category assesses the availability of healthcare services and providers within the plan's network. It considers factors like appointment wait times, ease of accessing specialists, and the availability of network providers in your area.

Customer Satisfaction: This category gauges the experiences of plan members, including their satisfaction with customer service, the ease of getting needed care, and the overall value of the plan.

Health Plan Performance: This category examines the plan's administrative efficiency, financial stability, and how well it manages the healthcare services provided to its members.

Prescription Drug Safety and Accuracy: This category is specific to Part D prescription drug plans and evaluates the plan's ability to ensure safe, accurate, and appropriate medication use. It includes measures such as medication adherence, drug safety, and the accuracy of drug pricing information.

These five categories are combined to produce an overall star rating for each plan, ranging from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). This rating serves as a snapshot of the plan's quality, making it easier for you to compare different options at a glance.

medicare advantage star ratings: 5 stars with party hats

How Star Ratings Are Calculated

To calculate the star ratings, CMS gathers data from multiple sources, ensuring a comprehensive and accurate assessment of each Medicare Advantage and Part D plan. The primary data sources include:

Surveys of Beneficiaries: CMS conducts annual surveys of plan members to gather their feedback on various aspects of their healthcare experience, such as satisfaction with customer service, assess to care, and overall plan value.

Clinical Data from Providers: CMS collects information from healthcare providers to evaluate the quality of care delivered to plan members. This data includes measures related to preventive screenings, chronic disease management, and health outcomes.

Health Plan Reporting: Plans are required to submit certain performance data to CMS, including information on administrative efficiency, financial stability, and the management of healthcare services provided to members.

To calculate the overall star rating for each plan, CMS assigns scores to individual measures within each of the five main categories mentioned in the previous section. These scores are then weighted based on their importance and relevance to beneficiaries' healthcare experience.

Once the weighted scores are calculated, they're combined to produce a single overall score for each plan. This score is then translated into a star rating, ranging from one to five stars, with five stars indicating the highest quality.

It's important to note that the star ratings are updated annually, so they may change as new data becomes available or as plans make improvements to their services. This means it's a good idea to review the star ratings each year during the Annual Election Period (AEP) to ensure you're enrolled in a plan that continues to meet your needs.

How to Use Star Ratings to Compare Plans

When comparing Medicare Advantage and Part D plans using star ratings, it's crucial to understand the significance of each rating category. Keep in mind that your individual needs and priorities may vary, so some categories may be more important to you than others. For example, if you have a chronic condition, you might place a greater emphasis on the quality of care category, whereas if you travel frequently, you may prioritize access to care.

In addition to the star ratings, there are several other factors to consider when comparing plans:

Individual Needs and Priorities: Assess your healthcare needs and priorities, such as the types of services you require, the medications you take, and the healthcare providers you prefer to see. This will help you determine which plan features are most important to you and how they align with the plan's star ratings.

Geographic Location: Part C and Part D plans may vary by region, and the availability of providers and services can differ depending on your location. Be sure to review the plan's network and service area.

Availability of Providers: Check the plan's provider network to confirm that your preferred doctors, specialists, and healthcare facilities are included. If you have specific healthcare providers you want to continue seeing, this can be an important factor in your decision-making process.

While star ratings offer a valuable snapshot of a plan's quality, they should be used in conjunction with other plan information to make the most informed decision. Consider the following tips when comparing plans:

  1. Review the plan's Summary of Benefits, which provides detailed information on covered services, costs, and any additional benefits the plan may offer.

  2. Research the plan's formulary, or list of covered prescription drugs, to ensure that your medications are included and to understand any cost-sharing requirements.

  3. Speak with a licensed insurance agent who can help you navigate the various plan options and provide personalized guidance based on your individual needs and circumstances.

By taking a holistic approach and considering star ratings along with other plan information, you'll be better equipped to make an informed decision about your Medicare coverage.

Impact of Star Ratings on Plan Enrollment and Benefits

The Medicare Star Ratings system not only serves as a valuable tool for beneficiaries but also encourages health plans to continuously improve their quality and performance. Plans with higher star ratings are more attractive to potential enrollees, leading to increased membership and, in turn, greater financial stability. As a result, health plans have a strong incentive to invest in improvements that directly benefit their members.

Plans that consistently achieve high star ratings may be eligible for bonus payments from CMS. These additional funds can be used by the plans to enhance their offerings and provide extra benefits to their members, such as reduced premiums, lower out-of-pocket costs, or expanded coverage for certain services.

Medicare Advantage and Part D plans are permitted to use their star ratings in marketing materials, showcasing their high-quality offerings and appealing to prospective enrollees. This marketing advantage further motivates health plans to prioritize quality improvement efforts and maintain high star ratings.

The Medicare star ratings system not only empowers beneficiaries to make informed decisions about their healthcare coverage but also drives improvements in the quality and performance of Medicare Advantage and Part D plans. By choosing a plan with a higher star rating, you can feel confident that you're enrolling in a plan that meets high standards for quality and service.

As you navigate the complex world of Medicare, remember that you don't have to do it alone. At Local Medicare Specialists, our team of licensed insurance agents is here to provide personalized guidance and support to help you find the plan that's right for you. To explore your Medicare plan options and receive expert assistance, contact Local Medicare Specialists today. We're committed to helping you make the best possible decision for your healthcare coverage.

Still Have Medicare Questions?

Schedule a FREE Medicare plan consultation with an agent in your neighborhood.


Privacy and Security: Your privacy and security are extremely important to us. Your personal information is protected by our Privacy Policy is privately owned and operated by LMS Insurance LLC. is a non-government resource for those who depend on Medicare, providing Medicare information in a simple and straightforward way.

We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area which are United Healthcare, Aetna, Humana, Cigna, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona, Centene, Devoted, and Scan. Please contact, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program to get information on all of your options.

tracking pixel